课程链接在此: 3.3 How to peer review a review articleresearcheracademy.elsevier.com/navigating-peer-review/certified-peer-reviewer-course/33-peer-review-review-article 因为是全英文授课,我自己记录课程讲义并做了中文翻译,只是记课堂笔记,顺便发出来方便有需要的人。 前面一部分是判断要不要接受审稿的过...
如何看待当前论文投稿的同行评审(Peer Review)模式? 返朴 科普话题下的优秀答主 同行评审(peer review)制度是现代学术研究的关键环节之一。通过同行审议程序,审稿人确定论文的原创性、正确性与重要性,并判定是否值得发表在对应的杂志上。然而,同行评审也存在种种弊端。那么,同行… ...
A Peer Review How-To. The article presents the author's suggestions for reviewers related to effective article reviewing. It is suggested that a reviewer should be prompt and th... Zucker,S Robert - 《Science》 被引量: 20发表: 2008年 A review of the peer review process and implications ...
This article describes the process of peer review from receipt of an article by a journal to publication. The need for timely response is explained. The importance and method of completing a helpful peer review is detailed. Specifically the areas of originality, structure, language, and ethical ...
Dear editor: My recommendation is minor revision and I would happy to review the revised article. Firstly, one of the conclusions concluded inappropriately. Secondly, concerning discussions, it would be better if reasons why medical data only sampled from tertiary hospitals and the implications on th...
Peer Review Peer review is defined as a critical evaluation, conducted by one or more experts in the relevant field, of either a scientific document—such as a research article submitted for publication, a grant proposal, or a study protocol—or a research program. One requisite element for p...
peer-reviewed Journals的意思是：同行评审期刊 一种学术期刊，要求提交出版的每一篇文章都由一个独立的专家小组进行评判。未经大多数同行批准的文章不被《华尔街日报》接受出版。其他短语表达：1、core journal 核心期刊 2、journal article 期刊论文；期刊文章 3、official journal 官方杂志；官方公报 4、...
英文论文状态in peer review是什么意思?代表你的论文正处于编辑部的初步审核阶段,如果这个状态持续了一周左右,那么很可能编辑正在对投稿进行评估,决定你的论文是否适合进行同行评审。此外,还有两种可能的结果:一种是要求你修改后重新提交,这通常是一个积极的信号;另一种是desk rejection,这意味着你的论文在本期刊发表...
6. Under Review(Peer review): 审稿人正在审稿。此时论文是由同行评审进行外审,因为审稿是无偿的工作加上需要付出许多精力,这个过程需要持续较长时间,一般为 1-2 个月。如果被邀请审稿人取消审稿,就会 decline,编辑会重新邀请别的审稿人。 同行评审是 SCI 论文审稿中耗时最久,也是影响杂志社决定最关键的环节。
This article argues that the theoretical and methodological divisions within economics combined with the institutional arrangement of the Research Assessment Exercise and peer review has produced a state affairs which poses a serious risk to the future existence of non-mainstream economics. The conclusion...