Response Letter sampleDear Dr./Prof.XXXX, Thank you very much for your decision letter and advice on our manuscript (Manuscript #) entitled “XXXXXX”.We also thank thereviewersfor theconstructive and positivecomments and suggestions. Accordingly, we haverevised the manuscript.Allamendmentsare ...
SAMPLE RESPONSE TO REVIEWERS’ COMMENTS Below are actual comments to a review I wrote sometime ago. I include it here so you can see the level of detail/discussion I expect for your letter. Also, though you don’t have to do it for my class; if you’re doi ng it for an actual...
如何回复审稿人意见(Response to Reviews).pdf,SAMPLE RESPONSE TO REVIEWERS’ COMMENTS Below are actual comments to a review I wrote sometime ago. I include it here so you can see the level of detail/discussion I expect for your letter. Also, though you don
总之，让Response Letter不再是针对审稿人质疑的【被动回复】，而是展现修改深度和论文价值的【主动引导】...
3、比起response letter,我更关注你的文章本身修改的如何; 有的response看似非常丰富,其实很多文字和图都是重复的,补充的一点点数据被反复拿来回答多个问题,非常令人反感。很多稿件response写的很好,有些之前提出的疑问也被说服了,但是正文没有怎么修改,只能拒稿处理就非常可惜。我见过有用表格的形式来写response,把回...
Writing a well-constructed response letter to the reviewers, with well-reasoned arguments, is a key part of the reviewing process. Although the manuscript is the main focus of the submission, the content and tone of the response letter can have a surprisingly large impact on the eventual ...
cover letter和 response to reviewers 开头都写 dear editor 就行了~保准没问题
值得注意的是,Response letter是发给编辑看的,虽然其他审稿人也能看见你的Peer Review File,但还是应该在回复的过程中使用第三人称提及审稿人,如“We agree with the reviewer”而不是“We agree with You”。 增加数据/图表 We have added a comment in the section “...” to point out the... we have...
值得注意的是,Response letter是发给编辑看的,虽然其他审稿人也能看见你的Peer Review File,但还是应该在回复的过程中使用第三人称提及审稿人,如“We agree with the reviewer”而不是“We agree with You”。 增加数据/图表 We have added a comment in the section “...” to point out the... ...
doi:info:doi/10.1002/stvr.1604Offutt, JeffSoftware TestingOffutt, J.: How to write an effective `Response to Reviewers' letter. Softw. Test. Verif. Reliab. 26(13), 174-175 (2016). http://cs.gmu. edu/~offutt/stvr/26-3-May2016.html...