polymers，两个审稿人意见返回后，主编给了Minor Revisions for acceptance。
Once you have revised the paper accordingly, please submit it together with a detailed description of your response to these comments. Please, also include a separate copy of the revised paper in which you have marked the revisions made. To submit a revision, please go tohttp://ees.elsevier....
since your target journal has used “Revisions Required,” it seems likely that they mean that minor revisions are required, and they probably use a different status to indicate “Major Revisions Required.” If you need confirmation, however, you can reach out to th...
as I’ve had authors at the “minor revisions” stage push back against smallish but important changes. This was frustrating for me (and I’m sure it was for the authors too), but it would have been a lot
The part about ‘Editing Checklist’ could refer to the check by the AE/ME for the minor revision fixes or it could refer to the check by the editing team once the AE/ME gives their acceptance. If the latter, it means that the editing team will prepare the manuscript ...
There is a contradiction in your statements. You mention that the status is “Awaiting reviewer selection” under “Minor revision” and you also mention that you re-submitted your manuscript after major revisions. In the case of major revisions, the manuscript d...
Thank you for this question. Some journals do have a policy of sending revised files back to the same reviewer for the final nod after the author has made the revisions they requested. This is even more so if the revision made following their criticism was a technical one. In such cases,...
What does "under review" after minor revisions indicate? How long should I wait for the status "Decision in process" after minor revision? Should I get my paper professionally edited if I have received minor revisions? Hope that helps. All the best in these final stages!
I have been asked to complete moderate revisions for a journal. I am aware that you have to track changes made to the manuscript in reference to reviewers comments and also for this particular journal provide a (separate) response to reviewer comments detailing all changes made....