Once you have revised the paper accordingly, please submit it together with a detailed description of your response to these comments. Please, also include a separate copy of the revised paper in which you have marked the revisions made. To submit a revision, please go tohttp://ees.elsevier....
as I’ve had authors at the “minor revisions” stage push back against smallish but important changes. This was frustrating for me (and I’m sure it was for the authors too), but it would have been a lot
Q: What does ‘Awaiting Approval/Editing Checklist’ mean after submitting my paper for minor revisions? Detailed Question - I have submitted my paper after making the minor revisions. Kindly let me know what the above status message means. ...
Following acceptance of this letter, in April 2008 Biological Conservation changed their online instructions to authors removing reference to an anonymous cover page. The authors support increased transparency regarding review methods by all journals such as the clarification made by Biological Conservation....
Within a short period of time after submission, the status message showed ‘accept pending minor revisions.’ The only comment I received was: "Please check your paper for English language editing, and ensure that you follow the Editorial Formatting Comments listed in this letter. Congratulati...
form, that is based on (or derived from) the Work and for which the editorial revisions, annotations, elaborations, or other modifications represent, as a whole, an original work of authorship. For the purposes of this License, Derivative Works shall not include works that remain separable from...
since your target journal has used “Revisions Required,” it seems likely that they mean that minor revisions are required, and they probably use a different status to indicate “Major Revisions Required.” If you need confirmation, however, you can reach out to the...
What does "under review" after minor revisions indicate? How long should I wait for the status "Decision in process" after minor revision? Should I get my paper professionally edited if I have received minor revisions? Hope that helps. All the best in these final stages!
Thank you for this question. Some journals do have a policy of sending revised files back to the same reviewer for the final nod after the author has made the revisions they requested. This is even more so if the revision made following their criticism was a technical one. In such cases,...