Be thorough: As a paper reviewer, it's important to provide detailed feedback that covers all aspects of the paper, including its strengths and weaknesses. Be constructive: Feedback should be helpful, not hurtful. Try to frame your comments in a way that's constructive and focused on improv...
Before starting to write a review, it is important to determine what kind of review you want to write and follow the appropriate style and guidelines. An effective literature review is important for the complete life cycle of a research from defining the right research goals to correctly interpre...
They should then provide numbered comments detailing points to be addressed by the author(s). All requested major revisions should be clearly outlined. Minor revisions should also be mentioned where the peer reviewer feels these will improve the clarity and purpose of the manuscript. When writing n...
Conference Reviewing Conference Reviewing Author has spent many hours to write the paper Reviewer is the only person actually reading it Usually, only the final score (accept/reject) is considered! Reviewing is a big responsibility How to deal with the load How to deal with the load Typical ...
How to respond to peer reviewer comments - A template_0.docx Download3 claps for this article https://doi.org/10.34193/EI-A-5194 Published on: Oct 16, 2013 Peer Review Process Author Mriganka Awati Mriganka writes, reviews, and plans educational or informational content aimed at researc...
How to write a review.如何些综述文章,英文版
For each reviewer, copy/paste each comment, unedited. Thenreply to each one in turn, citing the corresponding change in the manuscript byreferring to page, paragraph, and line number(or just line number, if you’re using continuous line numbering). Number the comments and make sure you repl...
thoughts, tips, and resources for mastering the art of writing a good academic paper and getting it published. I will share my experience as an author and reviewer and ask successful colleagues for theirs. Follow this website, and over the next months, you will find advise on themes, such...
How to write a review.如何些综述文章,英文版
You’ve got a great book, but now you have to write something that might feel even harder — a knockout query letter. If you’re struggling to write your query and cursing their very existence, don’t worry, I completely agree. They suck. ...