Tools & resources Articles from Reviewers' Update Connect Paving the way to increase diversity in journals – and research
Of course. Scientists are humans. There is always the possibility of revising a claim on the basis of new evidence. Some people argue that we should not trust science because scientists are “always changing their minds.” While examples of truly settled science being overturned are far fewer ...
Provide evidence: Whenever possible, back up your comments with evidence from the paper or other sources. This adds weight to your feedback and helps the authors understand your perspective. Use a professional tone: Remember that as a paper reviewer, you're providing feedback to colleagues in y...
The second pass should take up to an hour. After this pass, you should be able to grasp the content of the paper. You should be able to summarize the main thrust of the pa- per, with supporting evidence, to someone else. This level of detail is appropriate for a paper in which you...
your reasons behind it. These usually have to do with the manuscript’s scientific soundness, novelty, quality, importance, and suitability for the journal. Editors take many factors into consideration when deciding whether a paper is right for their journal so providing evidence or reasoning for ...
The scholarly book review serves many purposes and has the potential to be an influential literary form. The process of publishing a successful scholarly book review requires the reviewer to appreciate the book review publication process and to be aware of the skills and strategies involved in ...
I trust it goes without saying that a consensus which is truth preserving and uncontroversial, when released publicly by C, is meant to do just what it says on the tin; this would clearly not count as a perorative at t1. But suppose that consensus were overturned by contrary evidence so...
delivered your review, you might want to make use of elsevier’s reviewer hub opens in new tab/window to ensure that you receive credit for your work. the platform provides a private profile page, certificates, editor recognition as well as discounts for elsevier services. do not forget that...
So, putting Google reviews on the website is like spotlighting these real stories and showing evidence that they are great at what they do. Beyond enhancing their reputation, this practice extends a welcoming hand to more leads, encouraging them to approach their services with confidence and enth...
Avoid teaching about something that is too specialized and directly extracted from your research—you want to show breadth. The audience will be looking for evidence of teaching effectiveness and enthusiasm for teaching. Do not go over the allotted time for the activity. The demonstration lesson ...