Become a reviewer | Things to consider | What to include | Your recommendation | Webinar | Web of Science Academy Peer review is essential for filtering out poor quality articles by assessing the validity and integrity of the research. We value the work
Look for the “intellectual plot-line” of the article. You can do this from first skimming through the manuscript and then giving it a once-over read. As you do this, ask the five major questions that are central to the research review process: What do the researchers want to find out?
How to peer review a review article? 3.3 How to peer review a review articleresearcheracademy.elsevier.com/navigating-peer-review/certified-peer-reviewer-course/33-peer-review-review-article 因为是全英文授课,我自己记录课程讲义并做了中文翻译,只是记课堂笔记,顺便发出来方便有需要的人。 前面一部分...
A literature review is a survey of scholarly knowledge on a topic. Our guide with examples, video, and templates can help you write yours.
Arguably, the hallmark of scientific research is to have impact, both theoretical and practical, and to enhance scientific and technological understanding. One of the most commonly accepted means by which to achieve this impact is to promote broad dissemination of research findings through peer-...
It allows me to estimate the amount of time required to review a set of papers. More- over, I can adjust the depth of paper evaluation depending on my needs and how much time I have.5. RELATED WORKIf you are reading a paper to do a review, you should also read Timothy Roscoe’s ...
Do the authors cite many review articles? It is better to cite the original studies. Are all of the citations helpful to the reader? Note any places where the authors seem to be reviewing literature simply to show the depth of their knowledge, or to increase citations of their own previou...
What is a book review? A book review is an honest reaction to a book that generally analyzes its themes, plotline, characters, dialogue, and use of literary devices (if applicable). Through this analysis, written in the first person, a reviewer combines their opinions with insights about the...
Review articles can be loosely classified into two basic types, non-systematic and systematic ones. The non-systematic type may include a selection of a wide range of technical results related to a chosen topic which reflects the professional experiences and interests of the authors. The quality ...
It will also provide you with an overview of the new advances in the field and help you when writing and submitting your own articles. A common mistake is writing an unfocused review that is lost in the details. As a junior researcher, it may feel a little weird or daunting to critique...