How to review a journal article: questions of quality, contribution, and appealPeer reviewing is essential in ensuring high-quality academic publishing. Yet the whole process of reviewing for an academic journal remains a relatively hidden process. Very little guidance is giv......
Your evaluation to the editor: Should this paper be rejected for this journal? or does it show sufficient promise for revision, in ways that you have clearly demonstrated in your review, to encourage the authors to invest weeks and months in revision for this journal? Your bottom-line advice ...
1. Create a journal-specific reviewer account on Sage Track. Search for the journal’s name here and then click the ‘Submit paper’ link. This will take you to the peer review system where you can create an account. Why create an account on a specific journal Sage Track site? You wi...
How to review journal manuscripts Reviewing manuscripts is central to editorial peer review, which arose in the early 1900s in response to the editor's need for expert advice to help select... RM Rosenfeld - 《Otolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery》...
? Is the topic of interest to readers of the journal? ? Does the study try to answer important questions that have not been answered adequately? Provenzale and Stanley, AJR 2005 How to Review A Manuscript ? ? ? ? ? As an Editor I prefer a structured, numbered approach Highlight very ...
附件RAinstr13.pdf 我感觉也没什么内容,这个和第二轮审稿没关系,而且都是一些最基本的内容,比如:Novelty: Indicate in your review if the conclusions are novel or are too similar to work already published. 不过了解这些还是对自己写文章有点用处的。
Ask yourself: ‘Do I have to read it all? Which part will give me what I need?’ Maybe you have a journal article and only want to know the findings. It might therefore be worthwhile to scan through the article until you reach the ‘findings’ and ‘conclusion’ sections. ...
Being invited to review a manuscript is an honor, not only because you are being recognized for your eminence in a particular area of research but also because of the responsibility and service you provide to the journal and scientific community. The purpose of this article is to define how ...
the article. Or, copy the table of contents of the journal or book. Double check when you copy the information that you have all the bibliographic information. I can’t tell you how frustrated I was when trying to write a reference list when I had forgotten to get all of the ...
These keywords help you torank your journal. These keywords are searched by the many students and researchers for the information on google. 3 Abstract A well-written abstract is essential for your article review assignment. Your audience will first go to your abstract to determine if your ...