一篇良好的review应该具有以下几个特点:1. Identify key contributions and problems in the manuscript2. Provide constructive suggestions for manuscript to the author3. Provide consistent support for a recommendation to the editor 除此之外,review应当在限定时间内完成,做到efficiency。与此同时,被编辑和reviewer...
我还是来学习一下how to review & how to write a review report吧,以下是心雨奶奶review相关的文献阅读总结——Elaine Romanelli提到人们主要采用两种方式做review:一种是逐字逐句、一章一章地写;一种是全文浏览后对重要问题做review,从而定位整篇paper的contribution。
3.3 How to peer review a review articleresearcheracademy.elsevier.com/navigating-peer-review/certified-peer-reviewer-course/33-peer-review-review-article 因为是全英文授课,我自己记录课程讲义并做了中文翻译,只是记课堂笔记,顺便发出来方便有需要的人。 前面一部分是判断要不要接受审稿的过程,直接跳过,贴...
篇1:review写作指导:How to review Vol.6 读Paper | How to review 作为一枚硕士狗还能得到Review paper的权利,简直是最大的神奇故事,为了不把事情搞砸,我还是来学习一下how to review & how to write a review report吧,以下是心雨奶奶review相关的文献阅读总结——Elaine Romanelli提到人们主要采用两种方式做re...
how to write a review 如何写英语点评评论 Review侧重于实用性 三大要点：※1.PersonalityCOMEOUT!–从自己的角度出发评论，主观地表达你对主体的喜恶，尽可能客观地描述所见所闻。※2.Explainthepoint.–无论好坏都要用除了“好”和“坏”以外的词语去形容“好”“坏”。–生动地描述。•3.Shortsentence.–...
How to write a review.如何些综述文章,英文版
The system of peer review is not good at providing feedback to reviewers, but getting more invitations to review papers is a good sign that your review has been valued.doi:10.1111/ijau.12172David HayJohn Wiley & Sons, LtdInternational Journal of Auditing...
附件RAinstr13.pdf 我感觉也没什么内容,这个和第二轮审稿没关系,而且都是一些最基本的内容,比如:Novelty: Indicate in your review if the conclusions are novel or are too similar to work already published. 不过了解这些还是对自己写文章有点用处的。
How to write a review.如何些综述文章,英文版.pdf,How to write a review How to write a review Boi Faltings Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (EPFL) Outline Outline • Importance of Reviewing • Conference Reviewing • Journal Proposal Reviewing
Be thorough: As a paper reviewer, it's important to provide detailed feedback that covers all aspects of the paper, including its strengths and weaknesses. Be constructive: Feedback should be helpful, not hurtful. Try to frame your comments in a way that's constructive and focused on improv...