Editorial: How to review an article for a research journal - And what to expect as an author This editorial presents my opinion on how a reviewer should approach the task of reviewing a paper for a journal. The system of peer review is not good at providing feedback to reviewers, but ...
Peer review is an essential part of publishing review articles, just like it is for research articles. Yet, without any experimental procedures to evaluate, data to assess, or conclusions to interpret, it isn’t always clear what you’re being asked to c
考虑re-review是否有必要,re-review对于review来说比research articles 更加稀少。 四, 我评审了之后会发生什么? 编辑会等待有足够的review之后,返回修改意见。 作者会回复修改意见 编辑会决定要不要re-review 编辑最终决定Accept or rejection 五, 10个 dos & don'ts of peer reviewing a review article 提出专业...
How to peer review Evaluating the discussion and conclusion In the Discussion and Conclusion sections, authors should interpret the results, place them in context of previous findings, and explain what they mean for future research, as well as for possible real-life applications. If the author ...
Journals use peer review to both validate the research reported in submitted manuscripts, and sometimes to help inform their decisions about whether or not to publish that article in their journal. If the Editor does not immediately reject the manuscript (a “desk rejection”), then the editor ...
Look for the “intellectual plot-line” of the article. You can do this from first skimming through the manuscript and then giving it a once-over read. As you do this, ask the five major questions that are central to the research review process: ...
6 Literature Review: Writing Tips Writing a literature review for a research paper is an important stage in the academic research process. It entails doing a critical review of existing literature to provide a comprehensive overview of current knowledge on a certain issue. In this article, we wil...
question does not require you to respond to a list of specific questions, you might find it useful to consider these questions and the below generic points when you are preparing your review report. full length research article examine the importance of the research question addressed in the ...
Writing a research paper doesn’t have to be intimidating. Our handy guide to research papers will help you make the grade.