课程链接在此: 3.3 How to peer review a review articleresearcheracademy.elsevier.com/navigating-peer-review/certified-peer-reviewer-course/33-peer-review-review-article 因为是全英文授课,我自己记录课程讲义并做了中文翻译,只是记课堂笔记,顺便发出来方便有需要的人。 前面一部分是判断要不要接受审稿的过...
HOW TO REVIEW A PAPER The purpose of this article is to define how best to peer review an article. We will stipulate several principles of peer review and discuss some of ... DJ Benos,KL Kirk,JE Hall - 《Advances in Physiology Education》 被引量: 214发表: 2003年 Scholars Test Web ...
This article describes the process of peer review from receipt of an article by a journal to publication. The need for timely response is explained. The importance and method of completing a helpful peer review is detailed. Specifically the areas of originality, structure, language, and ethical ...
所有的研究人员在其工作中都会遇到同行评审,或作为作者,向专业期刊投稿发表研究工作;或作为审稿人,由期刊编辑邀请对他人的稿件提供审稿意见。 尽管同行评审是科研过程的一个重要方面,但大学中很少教过如何做,因此对新手来说,这可能是一项艰巨任务。与科研、教学和撰写论文相比,评审别人的工作似乎看起来更轻松一些。但...
有道理,做好笔记之后,写review就很简单了。 A few hours. I like to use two sittings, even when I am pretty sure of my conclusions. Waiting another day always seems to improve the review. - Callaham Normally, a peer review takes me 1 or 2 days, including reading the supporting information...
2.Review Decision: Accept:Paper is well written and a significant contribution to the literature. Minor Revisions:Issues that must be addressed by the author(s) before publication in order to adhere to scientific reporting standards, or issues affecting clarity. ...
This peer review tutorial will give you the skills needed to evaluate another researcher’s manuscript in a way that will help a journal Editor make a decision about publication.
Become a reviewer | Things to consider | What to include | Your recommendation | Webinar | Web of Science Academy Peer review is essential for filtering out poor quality articles by assessing the validity and integrity of the research. We value the work
How_to_Write_a_Review_Article How to Write a Review Article The process of academic writing should not be molded from technical clichés or reduced to a list of tips and tricks in targeting an easy publication. This brief contribution does not impose some strict rules on the scholarly publicat...
Detail, clarity and a constructive approach: all these are key to a helpful review, writes Sophie Inge