Four simple tips to help you respond to reviewers’ comments and fast track your paper for a positive decision
In my first 100 days of editing the South African Journal of Animal Science, I have found that most authors are having difficulties in addressing and responding to reviewers'/editors' comments. Some authors have not been submitting response notes which clearly indicate how reviewers/editors' suggest...
Thank you for considering my article for publication in XXX [Journal Name]. I am grateful to you and the reviewers for the valuable suggestions provided. Here are responses to the reviewer comments: Comment 1: Language editing for the manuscript has been done. I have used the services ...
for the manuscripts to be submitted to Sports Biomechanics and how to respond to the reviewers' comments after a review. General and section-specific writing guidelines are presented along with the recommendations for the preparation of the point-by-point responses to the reviewers' comments.Y...
How to respond to comments by peer reviewersdoi:10.34193/ei-a-5194M. AwatiEditage InsightsAwati, M. "How to respond to comments by peer reviewers." Editage Insights (2013), http://www.editage.com/insights/how-to-respond-to-comments-by-peer-reviewers (April 2, 2015)....
Some reviewers just won’t like your business. It’s the price, the style, or one negative experience they’ve had with you. Sometimes, you can’t do anything to change their opinion. The good thing is you don’t have to. Respond with grace, apologize, and focus on getting more pos...
My recommendation is to treat the responses to the reviewers independently. So, if you respond to the point in the first review, then in your response to the second review, don’t refer back to the first review. Either duplicate your response for Reviewer 2 or put a single response at...
For example, if you conducted a survey to obtain your research results, your samples (participants) were asked to respond to the survey questions. However, you might have had limited ability to gain access to the appropriate type or geographic scope of participants. In this case, the people ...
To change the perception of reviewers:When you respond to a negative review which is fake and stand for yourself, you change the mindset of people reading the review. In this way, they get more inclined towards booking your property.
Some reviewers just won’t like your business. It’s the price, the style, or one negative experience they’ve had with you. Sometimes, you can’t do anything to change their opinion. The good thing is you don’t have to. Respond with grace, apologize, and focus on getting more pos...