How to respond to peer review commentsHow to respond to peer review comments - 2015 - Lectures - PCRonlineAndrew Ong
Thank you for considering my article for publication in XXX [Journal Name]. I am grateful to you and the reviewers for the valuable suggestions provided. Here are responses to the reviewer comments: Comment 1: Language editing for the manuscript has been done. I have used the services...
Editorial: How to respond to reviewers' comments 来自 Semantic Scholar 喜欢 0 阅读量: 91 作者: Muchenje, Voster 摘要: In my first 100 days of editing the South African Journal of Animal Science, I have found that most authors are having difficulties in addressing and responding to ...
if you respond to the point in the first review, then in your response to the second review, don’t refer back to the first review. Either duplicate your response for Reviewer 2 or put a single response at the beginning addressed to both reviewers. It’s a bit of a courtesy to bot...
During the peer review process, how should you respond to reviewers’ critiques of your paper?相关知识点: 试题来源: 解析 You should respond to every criticism, even if you don’t make the change that the reviewer requested 反馈 收藏
group all of the suggestions regarding the Results section together into a smaller category, it will be easier for you to tackle the revision systematically. Organizing all of the suggestions for the Introduction, literature review, data analysis, etc., will make it easier...
Understanding the benefits of providing peer feedback: how students respond to peers' texts of varying quality 来自 EBSCO 喜欢 0 阅读量: 300 作者:MM Patchan,CD Schunn 摘要: Prior research on peer assessment often overlooks how much students learn from providing feedback to peers. By practicing...
You’ll need to reply to praise as well as criticism. If the comment was ‘The authors have been thorough in explaining X and presenting Y’, respond by writing ‘Response:We thank the reviewer for their positive comment’. There isno need to thank the reviewer in every response. A direc...
The following is an example as to how to respond to a reviewer comment: Reviewer comment:“In your analysis of the data you have chosen to use a somewhat obscure fitting function (regression). In my opinion, a simple Gaussian function would have sufficed. Moreover, the resul...
The following is an example as to how to respond to a reviewer comment: Reviewer comment:“In your analysis of the data you have chosen to use a somewhat obscure fitting function (regression). In my opinion, a simple Gaussian function would have sufficed. Moreover, the resul...