Nagel famously uses his vivid example about the sensory apparatus of bats to illustrate the difficulty of providing a purely physical characterization of phenomenal experience. Adapting Thomas Aquinas's principle regarding the nature of divine omnipotence, I argue that the fact that we cannot know ...
本次课程将深入探讨两位著名哲家 Thomas Nagel 和 Frank Jackson 的观点,他们都对物理主义提出了挑战,并试图论证现象型意识的特殊性和不可还原性。我们将详细剖析他们的论证,并分析其对心灵哲学领域的影响,以及其引发的争议和后续发展。 二、Thomas Nagel 和“蝙蝠是什么感觉?”:跨物种视角的挑战 Thomas Nagel 在其...
THOMAS NAGEL:What Is It Like To Be a Bat(整理版).doc,THOMAS NAGEL:What Is It Like To Be a Bat From the Philosophical Review 83, no. 4 (October 1974), pp. 435-50. THOMAS NAGEL Thomas Nagel (1937- ) is a professor of philosophy at New York University. Hi
内容提示: Philosophical Review What Is It Like to Be a Bat?Author(s): Thomas NagelSource: The Philosophical Review , Vol. 83, No. 4 (Oct., 1974), pp. 435-450Published by: Duke University Press on behalf of Philosophical ReviewStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2183914Accessed: ...
THOMAS NAGEL:What Is It Like To Be a BatFrom the Philosophical Review 83, no. 4 (October 1974), pp. 435-50. THOMAS NAGEL Thomas Nagel (1937- ) is a professor of philosophy at New York University. His publications include The Possibility of Altruism and Mortal Questions. Consciousness is...
While he disagrees with Nagel's argument, Dan Dennett says that Nagel's famous 1974 article "What It's Like To Be A Bat" is "the most widely cited and influential thought experiment about consciousness." Nagel's thesis is that purely material theories of mind, including computational theorie...
-REVIEW: of Where the Conflict Really Lies: Science, Religion, and Naturalism by Alvin Plantinga(Thpomas Nagel, NY Review of Books) -ESSAY: Thomas vs. Thomas: A New Approach to Nagel’s Bat Argument(Yujin Nagasawa, Inquiry) -ESSAY: Richard Rorty, Thomas Nagel, and the Platonic Myth(Bill...
Thomas Nagel的意识理论 Thomas Nagel是一位著名的哲学家,他在意识研究领域的贡献主要体现在他对意识主观性的强调。Nagel最著名的工作之一是他的论文《成为蝙蝠是什么样子》(What is it like to be a bat?),在这篇文章中,他探讨了意识的主观体验和个体经验的独特性。
但是这不是我所说的问题。我想知道的是,作为一只蝙蝠对蝙蝠来说会是什么样。然而,如果我试图想象这一点,我受到自己的心灵力量的限制,而那些力量不足以完成这个任务。我无法通过想象来完成它,无论是想象在我现有的经验上增加一些,还是想象从现有的经验中逐步减去一些,或者想象既增加又减少同时作些修改。
THOMAS NAGEL Thomas Nagel (1937- ) is a professor of philosophy at New York University. His publications include The Possibility of Altruism and Mortal Questions. Consciousness is what makes the mind-body problem really intractable. Perhaps that is why current discussions of the problem give it li...